Who is Matsiman? Matsi China Donate to Matsiman Web Gold Spot Market Publications Update? Booklet
Messages Link to Matsiman Sponsors of Matsiman First Nations Wildcrafters BC Mushroom Appreciation Morels Search Engines
Stuart Horner Videos
Mushroom Pickers Strike
Matsutake Managers in Oregon Cascades Meet
New Zealand Matsi ?
Wild Gourmet Market Report
Is your Patch Being Logged
Mushrooms vs. Logs
Simple Forecasting
Effect of Harvest Techniques 
Colleges & University

Umpqua Matsutake  Study 

Marketing Matsutake Mushrooms
Canadian Studies, Articles  
U.S. Gov

Aug. 15, 2001

Chief, Division of Scientific Authority
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
4401 North Fairfax Drive
Room 750
Arlington, Virginia

Recommendations on Species To
Consider for Changes to the CITES

Re:  Tricholoma magnivelare

Based on my research (citation and summary results below) I do not think that Tricholoma magnivelare needs to be listed in the CITES Appendices.
The American matsutake can be sustainable harvested with proper management practices.

Thank you for considering my comments.

Daniel L. Luoma
Assistant Professor
Department of Forest Science
Oregon State University
Corvallis, OR  97331
Eberhart, J.L., Luoma, D.L., Pilz, D., Amaranthus, M.P., Abbott, R., and
Segotta, D.  1999.  Effects of harvest techniques on American Matsutake
(Tricholoma magnivelare) production.  Abstract Book.  IXth  International
Congress of Mycology.  Sydney, Australia.


The following treatments were implemented (one time),  each on a matsutake
fruiting in each of the three blocks at two sites:

1) NH - No matsutake harvest (control)

2) BMP - Best management practice - harvest with minimal disturbance (gentle rocking and pulling)

3) SR-R - Shallow raking of litter layers to the interface with the mineral soil surface, sporocarp removal, and careful replacement of the litter

4) SR-NR - Shallow raking of litter layers, sporocarp removal and NO replacement of the litter

5) DR-R - Deep raking of the litter layers and 10 cm of mineral soil, sporocarp removal and replacement of litter and mineral soil

6) DR-NR - Deep raking of the litter layers and 10 cm of mineral  soil, sporocarp removal and NO replacement of litter and mineral soil

Results showed that careful picking had no impact on sporocarp production. The  one-time shallow raking with the litter layer carefully replaced did not differ from the control.  When expected numbers of sporocarps were calculated,  the actual production of matsutake on deep rake treatments and the shallow rake without litter replacement treatment were significantly reduced (p 0.05).

Results were consistent across the two sites with regard to the lack of effect of the BMP and a one-time SR-R treatment as compared to the control. At Diamond Lake, the more severe treatments (SR-NR, DR-R, DR-NR) showed dramatic decreases in sporocarp numbers.  We expect that the effects of repeated raking would be more severe than those reported here for a one-time raking.

Given that one-time, shallow raking with careful replacement of the litter layer is not a viable management option to implement, raking is a prohibited commercial harvesting technique.

31686 Federal Register

US Government Links

Harvest Method Effect and Recovery
Boswell The Buck
Breakfast and Dinner at the Boswell
Year Round In Season Buyers

Buyer & Picker Contacts

Nothing To
Do With
Visitor's Articles and Letters
Misc Information Links
Buy or Sell Mushrooms
Mushroom Articles & Links
Visitor's Matsi Photo Gallery
Missing Children Pacific Northwest